It's the quotation marks.
As seen on these recipe cards from 1974, most of the dishes are not what they seem. They may be called "Brownies" or "Pie", but they are really made from Knox gelatine molded with chocolate extract or whipped evaporated milk served over toasted white bread crumbs. All combined with a few drops of food coloring of course.
The quotation marks make it "legal".
The freedom of modern day Weight Watchers is, of course, that no food is forbidden. No quotation marks are necessary!
So I had some pie the other night (not "pie"). I counted my Weight Watchers Points. It hurt, but I took my lumps and wrote it in my tracker.
This leaves me wondering...How my Weight Watchers Points do you think there are in "Pie"?
Don't even get me started...